What to Give Someone Who Has Everything (the Impossible Friend)
Every Secret Santa group has one. That friend who, when you read their name on the paper, makes you sigh: the impossible friend, the person who seems to have it all. They buy whatever they want whenever they want, never waiting for a special occasion, and they respond with "oh, I don’t need anything" when you ask them. Then comes the panic of trying to find a gift for someone who has everything without repeating something they already own in three different colors.
Relax. This challenge is more common than it seems — and there’s a solution. The secret is to stop competing with what the person can buy for themselves and focus on what they rarely purchase for themselves: time, experiences, exclusivity, and meaning.
Why the "Impossible Friend" is So Hard to Gift
Those who "have it all" rarely truly have everything. What they possess is easy access to what they desire. They don’t wait for gifts because when they want a new pair of headphones, they just buy them. So, common items lose their charm: you’ll never surprise someone with something they could purchase in two clicks.
The key shift is simple: stop thinking about "things" and start thinking about moments, flavors, gestures, or causes. These four options can solve almost any case of the impossible friend.
4 Sure-Fire Gift Ideas for Someone Who Has Everything
1. Experience (the gift that becomes a memory)
Those who have many possessions often lack time well spent. An experience doesn’t clutter up shelves and provides a story to tell.
- A class or workshop related to something they enjoy (pottery, wine, photography, cooking).
- Tickets to a concert, theater performance, exhibition, or their favorite sports game.
- A unique outing: guided hike, tasting, spa day, or escape room.
- An experience voucher from platforms that let them choose the date.
Experiences work especially well in Secret Santa because you already know each other well enough to hit the right note. And nothing stops it from being a two-person experience, with you included — turning the gift into a fun outing with friends.
2. Premium Consumables (they run out, so they’re never repeated)
The great advantage of consumables is that they don’t sit around unused: the person enjoys them, and the gift "disappears". This makes it immune to the "I already have one of those" response. The focus here is on above-average quality, that item they enjoy but might not splurge on for themselves.
- A special origin coffee, a rare tea, or artisanal chocolate.
- Premium olive oil, gourmet jam, a good wine, or spirit.
- A high-quality scented candle, handmade soap, or a nice skincare kit.
- A small, well-curated basket of complementary items.
Even within a set budget, premium consumables feel generous. If your group has agreed on a price range, you can hit the mark without overspending — it’s worth reviewing how much to spend on Secret Santa before you start shopping.
3. Handmade (what money can’t buy)
For someone who buys everything, what holds true value is what is not for sale. A gift made by you carries time and intention — two things the impossible friend rarely finds at the mall.
- Something you cook or prepare well: bread, cookies, preserves, or homemade sweets.
- A heartfelt letter, a photo album of your moments together, or a playlist with a note.
- Simple crafts: a framed picture, a plant you’ve cared for, or a hand-painted item.
- A "voucher" written by you: dinner voucher, cleaning voucher, or help with moving voucher.
It doesn’t have to be a work of art. Handmade gifts are touching precisely because they are imperfect and personal. For a long-time friend, it often becomes the gift they cherish — and that fits perfectly with the fun of the game among friends.
4. Donation in Their Name (a gift that does good outside)
When someone truly doesn’t need more material possessions, turning the value into a good cause is an elegant gesture. You make a donation in the friend’s name and present a card explaining what was done.
- Sponsor an animal from a shelter in their name.
- Donate to an organization they care about (education, hunger, environment, health).
- Plant trees through projects that issue a named certificate.
It’s a gift that says "I know you and I understand what you care about" without cluttering their home. It’s a great fit for those who are minimalists or conscious about consumption.
How to Figure Out What to Give Without Giving Away the Surprise
The impossible friend often says "I don’t need anything" — but they drop hints all the time. The good part about Secret Santa is that you can investigate without ruining the surprise.
- Use the wish list. When everyone creates theirs, even those who "have it all" end up revealing a small, specific desire.
- Ask in the anonymous chat. You can probe their tastes, sizes, and the causes they support without revealing your identity.
- Pay attention to complaints. Someone who says "I wish I had time to cook" is hinting at a class. Someone who mentions "I love this coffee but it’s expensive" is giving you the perfect consumable clue.
- Think about what they do for others. Often, the impossible friend is generous and never has time for themselves. Returning that care is already halfway there.
Quick Questions About the Impossible Friend
What if I mess up and they already have it? Experiences, consumables, handmade gifts, and donations are almost immune to "I already have that". That’s why they are the four favorite options for this profile.
Are there good gifts within a low budget? Yes. A special coffee, a thoughtful letter, or a symbolic donation work in any price range. The secret is in the curation, not the price.
What if the group consists of people who don’t know each other well? In that case, premium consumables and generic experiences (cultural vouchers, gift vouchers from platforms) are the safest bets. If you want to be bold, check out ideas for creative Secret Santa.
The App That Makes the "Impossible" Friend Less Impossible
The biggest pain point in gifting someone who has everything is the guessing game. With O Amigo Secreto, each participant creates their wish list, you chat anonymously to gather hints, and the draw is fair and secret even from the organizer. The impossible friend becomes much less impossible when they provide the clues themselves — without even realizing it.
Want more inspiration before making your decision? Check out the extensive list of gift ideas for Secret Santa.
👉 Download for free
Also read:
Ready for your Secret Santa?
Create a group, invite with a link and run a fair, secret draw in seconds. Free.
oamigosecreto.app/baixar/